Getting things ready for you... 0%

Concordia Theological Quarterly · Book Review

Becoming Lutheran: The Community of Brunswick from Evangelical Reform to Lutheran Culture

by John A. Maxfield

Becoming Lutheran: The Community of Brunswick from Evangelical Reform to Lutheran Culture. By John A. Maxfield. St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 2024. 394 pages. Hardcover.

The relation between Christian teaching and society has been hotly contested in recent years. Maxfield in this text outlines the development of a Lutheran society in Brunswick following the preaching of the gospel. He does this by evaluating the effect that pamphlets had on the people and governing bodies of Brunswick. His research is impeccable and thorough. The story of Brunswick at the beginning of the Reformation to the end of the 1550s is well chronicled in a readable and interesting fashion. Those with an introductory knowledge of the Reformation will benefit from this text, as it deepens our understanding of this period in a specific town. Those interested in historical research will be benefited by the copious bibliography which follows the text. Pastors in challenging situations will be strengthened by hearing that through preaching and teaching a true and God-pleasing reform is possible as it was in Brunswick.

A point of criticism can be made regarding one of his conclusions. Maxfield contends that Brunswick’s institution of Lutheran society through civil ordinances mirrored Luther’s experience of Christian freedom. As Luther experienced freedom through the gospel from religious tyranny, so too did Brunswick experience freedom from Roman Catholic political influence and so was able to institute a Lutheran society with all the necessary civil and religious reforms. The question to be asked is, can Luther’s spiritual notion of Christian freedom translate to a city, which is a corporate and physical thing? Luther’s notion of Christian freedom belongs to the soul and is given through faith; Luther holds that these have nothing to do with civil governance. But on the other hand, Maxfield demonstrates that Brunswick’s reform was achieved through the persuasion of the people of Brunswick. This, along with the representative system of government in Brunswick, means that the changes were not imposed by force from outside, but freely adopted by the people.

Aaron Ferguson
Pastor, Christ Lutheran Church
Perry, Oklahoma

Want to read the book? Purchase a copy from the CTSFW bookstore.